![]() |
| (Amazon UK link) |
I read ‘The exiles’ at the end of December, and ‘The exiles at home’ in February. And I’ve just finished the third in the trilogy, ‘The exiles in love’, which I last read in 2012. Whereas the earlier two could be considered children’s books, this one is more for younger teenagers. And it’s slightly different in style.
The Conroy family are still the main focus of the book, but each chapter opens with a brief dialogue, between Ruth and Naomi, evidently some time after the events which they are describing. It felt a bit weird at first, but I quickly got used to it, and by the final chapters had realised what was going on, though it’s all very low key.
But the bulk of the story happens when Ruth is nearly fifteen, and Naomi thirteen. Rachel is ten, and Phoebe eight. Their characters are quite distinct, and I liked catching up with them again. The story is about the summer when they - Ruth and Naomi, anyway - started exhibiting the family failing: falling in love with totally unsuitable people.
It starts with a squashed hedgehog, which is rather sad, but Ruth then falls in love with the school bus driver. And she’s also rather keen on her new substitute teacher for Literature, who spends the lessons reading aloud from a variety of novels. Naomi finds him very attractive too. They’re the only two girls who have actually read most of the books in the school library, and Naomi in particular helps him to remember what he’s previously covered.
Then Ruth starts to fall for a young man in the sixth form at school, who’s helping out his uncle at the butcher’s shop. Oh, and she’s passionate about Mr Rochester in ‘Jane Eyre’ and keeps reading the book until it’s almost fallen to pieces.
Into the mix comes Philippe, a French teenager, the grandson of an old friend of Big Grandma’s. He comes to stay with the Conroys for a fortnight, and turns out to be charming, friendly, and very helpful around the house. All four girls fall a little bit in love with him, and Rachel asks if he will marry her. He says he will… and he also helps Rachel to change her appearance for the better.
Then the story moves to France where Big Grandma takes the four girls on a holiday, staying in a rather basic cottage with an outside toilet… there’s some humour as the girls experiment with their non-existent French as they try to go shopping…
I didn’t find this book quite as appealing as the earlier two, possibly because it’s more about Ruth and Naomi than about the younger ones. Phoebe is determined to be a spy when she grows up, and Rachel eats anything and everything, although there’s no mention of her being overweight. But - perhaps since it’s supposed to be Ruth and Naomi remembering - most of the story revolves around them. We see very little of their parents, and not a great deal of Big Grandma.
Still, it’s quite cleverly done, and I did appreciate that the end of the book brings a definite closure to the Conroy ‘Exile’ trilogy. Definitely recommended if you’ve read the first two, but it would seem a bit confusing to read this alone, as there are quite a few references to people who appeared in the earlier volumes.
Recommended to children of perhaps ten and upwards, or to adults who appreciate Hilary McKay’s style of writing.




