 |
| (Amazon UK link) |
This book was fine as a stand-alone read, although probably some things would have been clearer had I read the first book beforehand. There seemed to be rather a large cast - several vets, nurses and receptionists - although there was a helpful list at the front.
This particular novel focuses on Dan, a newly arrived temporary vet who is excellent at his work. But he speaks his mind, and expects others to work as hard as he does. Thus he quickly finds himself disliked.
At the same time there are many tensions in an almost soap opera style from the rest of the staff. Several of them appear to have shaky marriages or other problems at home, and these naturally impinge on their daily lives. I found the plot and many subplots interesting, but it all went rather too fast for my liking: in only a little over 250 pages there is a vast amount of action which could easily have filled a novel twice as long.
But as well as feeling that a lot was missing, I found the writing style a bit irritating at times. There is a lot of informal English, and some rather careless editing. Perhaps that's what happens when an author becomes well-known: her books will sell anyway, so there's no point tidying up strange sentences or making the language consistent. I realise this does happen in a lot of modern books, but it's usually the 'chick-lit' variety, and this story had the potential to be something more. James Herriot it's not - by a long chalk - but it could still have been a well-characterised, well-written insight into life in a large country vet practice. Unfortunately, it isn't.
Still, I kept reading and might look out for others in the series at second-hand shops, because I found myself becoming quite interested in some of the characters. Dan is well-written, if a bit stereotyped, and the senior partner Mungo is quite believable, along with his charming wife. The young student Kate who also takes a fairly major role has a lot of potential.
Other characters are rather flat, and some plot developments don't really work: people seem to change their view about Dan with no real reason, for instance. The end of the book also feels very rushed and - more significantly - simply produces an answer to a problem out of the blue, rather than anybody having to work for it.
At the same time there are many tensions in an almost soap opera style from the rest of the staff. Several of them appear to have shaky marriages or other problems at home, and these naturally impinge on their daily lives. I found the plot and many subplots interesting, but it all went rather too fast for my liking: in only a little over 250 pages there is a vast amount of action which could easily have filled a novel twice as long.
But as well as feeling that a lot was missing, I found the writing style a bit irritating at times. There is a lot of informal English, and some rather careless editing. Perhaps that's what happens when an author becomes well-known: her books will sell anyway, so there's no point tidying up strange sentences or making the language consistent. I realise this does happen in a lot of modern books, but it's usually the 'chick-lit' variety, and this story had the potential to be something more. James Herriot it's not - by a long chalk - but it could still have been a well-characterised, well-written insight into life in a large country vet practice. Unfortunately, it isn't.
Still, I kept reading and might look out for others in the series at second-hand shops, because I found myself becoming quite interested in some of the characters. Dan is well-written, if a bit stereotyped, and the senior partner Mungo is quite believable, along with his charming wife. The young student Kate who also takes a fairly major role has a lot of potential.
Other characters are rather flat, and some plot developments don't really work: people seem to change their view about Dan with no real reason, for instance. The end of the book also feels very rushed and - more significantly - simply produces an answer to a problem out of the blue, rather than anybody having to work for it.
No comments:
Post a Comment